settled-reach/tooling/DOMAINS.md

# The domain map (T-1271, D-263)

Every Python file and every executable in `tooling/`, assigned to a domain
before anything moves. This is the artefact the per-domain port tickets are
written from — without it their boundaries would be guesses, renegotiated
halfway through the move.

**Status:** map only. Nothing here has moved yet except `check client-version`,
which shipped in T-1262 as the reference implementation.

## What the survey changed

Two corrections to the T-1250 description, both found by counting rather than
reading:

- **Three Rust crates, not one.** `econ-sim`, `line-previewer` and `test-client`
  are all Cargo projects with zero `.py` files. None is renamed and none moves;
  a hyphen only matters for something Python must import.
- **The "28 singleton prefixes" were an artefact of my own measurement.**
  Splitting filenames on the first token scattered coherent families:
  `sculpt-star-map`, `tune-star-map-topology` and `generate-star-map*` are one
  group, not three orphans. Counting families instead of prefixes, the genuinely
  ambiguous set is small and is listed under *Judgment calls* below.

And two found while reading the tree:

- **`garment-fit/` is mostly a Blender payload directory.** 22 of its 23 files
  are `blender_author_*.py`, leaving one real module. So the Blender carve-out
  is **35 files**, not the 13 visible at top level — the T-1250 description was
  right about 35 and an intermediate survey of mine was wrong, because it
  counted only the top level. The consequence is not cosmetic: `character`
  is a much smaller domain than the directory sizes imply, and the carve-out is
  much larger.
- **`tooling/db/` is misnamed.** It holds the audio/image/Trellis connectors and
  `wiki_sync.py` — the actual database work is in `economy-db/`. Naming a domain
  `db` after that directory would carry the misnomer forward, so its contents
  split between `assets` and `wiki` instead.

## Half the executables are bash

Found 2026-08-31, after this map was first written and while starting the first
port. **17 of the 33 extensionless executables are bash**, ~900 lines. This map
originally assigned them as though they were Python files to be moved; they are
rewrites.

Decided: **rewrite all of them in Python** (D-263). Wrapping would achieve one
door while leaving half the surface outside the contract, so `reach --help`
would list verbs that behave differently from the ones beside them — worse than
two doors, because the inconsistency only shows up at a failure.

| shape | scripts | cost |
|---|---|---|
| thin wrappers | `atlas-systems-done` 9, `atlas-names` 17, `generate-brands` 23, `atlas` 24, `generate-corporations` 23, `blender` 28 | near-free; the router calls what the script called |
| logic | `check-fact-ids` 89, `validate-ron` 137, `godot-parse-sweep` 64, `godot-cold-parse` 96, `pr-watchlist-diff` 37, `atlas-update-field` 59, `atlas-commit-and-sync` 60, `tea-comment` 41 | real rewrite; gains the most — testable, failures that teach |
| environment | `install-godot` 108, `install-rust` 33, `worktree-setup` 49 | gains least, riskiest — port the *decision* logic, keep the external calls behind `core/process` |

A **bash** source turns a port from mechanical into a rewrite that needs its own
parity evidence. Each per-domain ticket must say which of its sources are bash.

## Domains

| domain | what it is | sources |
|---|---|---|
| `check` | repo consistency gates the push hook runs | `check-client-version` ✅, `check-canvas-version`, `check-systems-db-stamp`, `check-fact-ids`, `check-dataflow-graph.py` |
| `validate` | content and schema validation | `validate-content`, `validate-checklist`, `validate-ron` |
| `atlas` | the Atlas map data surface | `atlas`, `atlas-check`, `atlas-names`, `atlas-commit-and-sync`, `atlas-systems-done`, `atlas-update-field`, `atlas-verify`, `atlas-flatness` |
| `starmap` | the star map and its renders | `generate-star-map.py`, `generate-star-map-data.py`, `generate-star-map-svg.py`, `sculpt-star-map.py`, `tune-star-map-topology.py`, `star-map-seed.json` |
| `planet` | planetary generation and its guards | `planet-gen/` (30 files) |
| `db` | the economics DB pipeline | `economy-db/` (17 files), `schema_version.py` |
| `wiki` | wiki sync and content maintenance | `wiki/`, `db/wiki_sync.py`, `db/populate_gttr_hook.py`, `db/backfill_cultural_corridor.py`, `assign-astro-ids.py`, `fill-missing-globes.py`, `migrate-s-to-gj.py`, `patch-core-sector.py`, `process-wiki-system-changes` |
| `assets` | connectors to the tower-of-joy generators | `db/audio_*.py`, `db/audio-*`, `db/image_connector.py`, `db/trellis_connector.py`, `db/common.py`, `trellis-batch.sh`, `synth_ui_sounds.py` |
| `character` | bodies, garments, GLB handling | `garment-fit/make_logo.py`, `garment-qa/analyze_captures.py`, `convert_outfit.py`, `glb_strip_utility_nodes.py`, `inspect_glb.py`, `check_hair_symmetry.py`, `check_icosphere.py`, `render_quaternius_test.py`, `setup_clothing_metadata.py` — **note this is far smaller than `garment-fit/`'s file count suggests; 22 of its 23 files are Blender payloads and belong to the carve-out** |
| `visual` | screenshot and render comparison | `visual-diff`, `visual-thumbnail`, `visual-blank-check` |
| `godot` | Godot parse and cold-start checks | `godot-parse-sweep`, `godot-cold-parse` |
| `generate` | content generators not owned elsewhere | `generate-brands`, `generate-corporations`, `generate-character-manifest`, `generate_corp_stubs.py` |
| `dev` | developer environment and workflow | `install-rust`, `install-godot`, `worktree-setup`, `perf-baseline`, `clerk-review` |
| `pr` | the PR/review loop | `tea-comment`, `pr-watchlist-diff`, `pql-board-html` |
| `blender` | **carve-out** — payloads run by Blender | **35** `blender_*.py` (13 top-level + 22 in `garment-fit/`), `blender` wrapper → `tooling/scripts/blender/` |

## Judgment calls, with reasons

Each of these sets a precedent, so the reasoning matters more than the answer.

**Registries stay module-level data, not commands.** `canvas_sources.py` and
`generator_sources.py` are lists of paths consumed by gates — nothing types them.
They move beside the domain that reads them (`check` and `db` respectively) as
plain modules, not verbs. Making them commands would put something in
`reach --help` that answers no question a person has.

**`schema_version.py` belongs to `db`, and `check` imports it.** It is consumed
by the economics importer *and* by the stamp gate. Shared, but not equally
owned: the importer defines the version, the gate reads it. It goes where it is
defined, and the cross-domain import is legitimate — that is what a service
layer is for.

**`test_*.py` files do NOT become a domain.** They are gate tests run by
`make test-tooling`, not commands anyone types. `reach test …` would imply a
test runner that does not exist. They stay standalone scripts.

**`pql-migrate/` is provenance, not tooling.** One-shot scripts from a completed
migration, already documented as such in `.claude/rules/project-structure.md`.
They are not live tools and must not become verbs. Move to `tooling/archive/`,
excluded from package discovery — deleting them would destroy migration
provenance, and keeping them importable would imply they still run.

**`pr` is a domain the epic did not list.** `tea-comment` and `pr-watchlist-diff`
are the PR/review loop, which is neither `dev` (environment setup) nor anything
else on the original list. Folding them into `dev` would make `dev` the drawer
everything ambiguous goes into — which is how `core/` rots, and the same
argument applies here.

**`atlas` is overloaded, and the port must not merge the three uses.** The word
appears in three unrelated places: the top-level `atlas-*` executables (the map
data surface), `planet-gen/atlas_*.py` (`atlas_cohesion_audit`,
`atlas_common`, `atlas_quality_analysis` — quality analysis of generated
terrain), and `economy-db/atlas.py` (the atlas index tables in `systems.db`).
These are three concerns sharing a noun, not one domain in three places. Each
stays with its owner — `atlas`, `planet` and `db` respectively — and the port
should resist the pull to collect them, which would produce a domain whose only
common thread is a word.

**`economy-db/errors.py` predates `core/errors.py` and is not the same thing.**
Domain-local error types are fine; what must not happen is a silent merge, or a
second `ReachError` with different semantics. Reconcile explicitly when `db` is
ported.

**`character` rather than `garment`.** D-263's sketch says `garment`, but the
files cover bodies, hair, GLB utilities and Quaternius imports as well as
clothing. Naming it for one of its five concerns would leave the other four
looking misfiled.

## Not moving

| what | why |
|---|---|
| `econ-sim/`, `line-previewer/`, `test-client/` | Rust crates. Excluded from package discovery; hyphens are harmless. |
| `scripts/blender/` (after T-1273) | Run under Blender's bundled Python; cannot import `tooling.core`. Excluded from the conformance scope for the same reason. |
| `archive/` (was `pql-migrate/`) | Completed-migration provenance. |
| `test_*.py` | Gate tests, not commands. |

## Naming, applied on the way in

- **Modules** `snake_case`: `check-dataflow-graph.py` → `dataflow_graph.py`.
- **Verbs** `kebab-case`: `reach check dataflow-graph`.
- **No prefix-as-namespace.** The domain directory supplies what the `blender_`,
  `atlas-` and `check-` prefixes were doing by hand. `atlas-verify` becomes
  `reach atlas verify`, not `reach atlas atlas-verify`.
- **Layering is a vocabulary, not a quota.** A domain with only a router and a
  service gets exactly those two files. Empty `schemas.py` and `dependencies.py`
  are worse than absent ones — they suggest a shape the domain does not have.