Files
settled-reach/docs/workshops/v01-content-scoping/round2-si.md
T
jpmschweitzerandClaude Opus 4.6 b672b9c269 feat(docs): restructure wiki taxonomy with templates and Krenn System entry (#301, #319)
Move wiki from docs/wiki/ to root wiki/. Add 14 category templates with
YAML frontmatter, governance model, hierarchical spatial structure
(system > station > district > location). Populate Krenn System entry
as first concrete star system. Update cross-references in workshop and
sprint docs.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-02-13 00:58:45 +01:00

291 lines
22 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Round 2 — SI (Project Manager)
## Finalized Ticket List for v0.1 Content Scoping
Incorporates: all 7 Round 1 responses, Qatux tracking doc, lead decisions (D-NPC, D-FORMAT, D-INTERACT, D-PAUSE).
---
## 1. Lead Decisions — Impact on Tickets
| Decision | Ticket Impact |
|----------|---------------|
| **D-NPC:** Gestalt's mechanical mapping wins for v0.1 | NEW-1 simplified: "apply Gestalt's mapping" (not resolve disagreements). Paula's emotional layer becomes v0.2 annotation. |
| **D-FORMAT:** YAML for content, RON converter available | Confirms C-series as YAML. Adds NEW-8: RON converter tool. |
| **D-INTERACT:** Single action for v0.1, multi-verb architecture underneath | NEW-7 reframed. Adds NEW-9 (server: InteractionOptions) + NEW-10 (client: extensible prompt). |
| **D-PAUSE:** Spacebar always pauses, overlays = 50% sim speed | Adds NEW-11 (server: tick rate scaling) + NEW-12 (client: pause state machine). |
---
## 2. Round 1 Consensus — Impact on Tickets
| Consensus Item | Ticket Impact |
|----------------|---------------|
| **A-01:** Drin promoted to Tier 2 | NEW-2 changes from "evaluation" to "execute promotion" — expand profile. |
| **A-02:** NOBODY deferred to v0.2 | No v0.1 ticket. Hidden data ships in NPC YAML files (handled by C-series). |
| **A-05:** ~200 monologue lines | Sizes NEW-4 at ~200 lines (~100 per character). |
| **A-06:** ~695 total authored items | Overall content scope validation. No new ticket, but informs sprint capacity. |
| **A-07:** 3 active + 2 passive triangles | Confirms A11 scope (Triangle 1 only needs fixing). T3/T5 need less work. |
| **A-11:** THE FRIEND is critical path | Confirms #261#297/#298 chain is the highest-priority dependency. |
| **A-12:** Client receives text from server | No client-side content loading tickets needed. Simplifies client scope. |
| **A-14:** PC-as-NPC confirmed for v0.1 | Validates B3, B5, NEW-6. |
| **A-15:** News ticker confirmed for v0.1 | #306 confirmed. Scope: ~20 headlines. |
| **A-17:** Self-contained triangle forks | Reduces C8 complexity (no cross-triangle cascade logic). |
| **Tyre: Line previewer CLI** | Adds NEW-13. |
| **Paula: 7 additional wiki gaps** | Gaps 1-5 already covered by existing tickets. Gap 6 (location smuggler detail) → folded into content conversion. Gap 7 (Harek triangle membership) → folded into NEW-1 mapping. |
---
## 3. Existing Ticket Updates (Revised)
| ID | Title | Action | Sprint Target |
|----|-------|--------|---------------|
| #368 | Knowledge vocabulary for v0.1 content | **Close** — wiki at `wiki/` is the delivered output | Sprint 2 (done) |
| #369 | Wiki Review Workshop Outputs (epic) | **Repurpose** as parent epic for all v0.1 content scoping tickets. Update description. | — |
| #301 | Wiki taxonomy and structure | **Assign to copy.** Downscope: Sova district structure only for v0.1. Full 500+ world taxonomy is generator-era. | Sprint 3 |
| #319 | Krenn System wiki entry | **Merge with A3.** Expanded: wiki page + seed.yaml reference implementation. Assign to copy. | Sprint 4 |
| #261 | Dual Lens Authoring Guide | **CRITICAL PATH ROOT.** Assign to copy. Owner: Paula. Blocks 9 downstream tickets. | Sprint 3 (P0) |
| #310 | Character voice speech patterns | **Subsume into B4** (smuggler voice card + moral arc). B4 is the larger ticket. Close #310 when B4 lands. | Sprint 3 (via B4) |
| #306 | News ticker / Meridian feed content | **Confirm scope:** ~20 dual-lens headlines. Assign to copy. | Sprint 4 |
| #326 | YAML content loader | **Assign to server.** Blocked by C1 + C2. | Sprint 4 |
| #86 | Core NPC components | **Already Sprint 3 server.** Dudley's ECS component list from Round 1 informs this. | Sprint 3 |
| #88 | Daily routine system | **Already Sprint 3 server.** Needs NPC routine YAML from content conversion. | Sprint 3 |
---
## 4. Finalized New Ticket Proposals
### Group A: Wiki Content Fixes (copy team)
| ID | Title | Type | Priority | Sprint | Blocked By | Description |
|----|-------|------|----------|--------|------------|-------------|
| A1 | Apply canonical full names to all NPC wiki pages | task | medium | 3 | — | Apply Miri's 12 full names to NPC wiki pages. Update Core Identity blocks, environmental text references. |
| A2 | Rename Hael → Naia Tamm across all wiki files | task | medium | 3 | — | Find-and-replace across ~8 wiki files. Triangle 4 becomes Naia-Kael-Sera. |
| A6 | Add smuggler-perspective FactId progression text | task | high | 4 | B4 | Add smuggler-path text for all FactIds where smuggler starts at KnowsDetails or has different knowledge path. |
| A7 | Add smuggler-specific entity attributes to entity-attributes.md | task | high | 3 | — | Scope depends on Round 2 resolution of D-03 (Gestalt's 4 new + 2 repurposed vs Paula's 8 new). Add to wiki/knowledge/entity-attributes.md. |
| A8 | Standardize location shortcodes in monologue-guide.md | task | medium | 3 | — | Fix hub_m_ → terminal_m_ inconsistency. Add shortcode reference table. |
| A10 | Stub NPC profile for Nils Davan | task | medium | 3 | — | Off-stage profile: Core Identity, relationship to Kael, role in ring, known attributes. |
| A11 | Fix Triangle 1 (Hub Power) — Volume Escalation decision | story | high | 3 | A10 | Add smuggler decision fork: side with Nils (louder signal), side with Voss (tension), or split route (exposure). Self-contained — no cross-triangle cascade per A-17. |
| A12 | Create environmental text examples file | task | medium | 4 | A3/#319 | Bar menu, safety notice, news ticker cycle, corridor graffiti. Krenn-voiced. Needed for wow moment #1 (Arrival). |
### Group B: Style Guides & Specs (copy team)
| ID | Title | Type | Priority | Sprint | Blocked By | Description |
|----|-------|------|----------|--------|------------|-------------|
| B1 | NPC Authoring Style Guide | story | critical | 5 | A3, A4, A7, B2, B4 | Combined document: tier templates, authoring rules, regional culture, content pipeline. Reframed as generator specification — this IS the NPC generator input format. Most complex ticket; many blockers. |
| B2 | THE MIRROR pattern spec | story | high | 3 | — | Define honest-character NPC pattern. No contradiction arc, no secret. Tier 1 emotional depth. Naia Tamm is first instance. Output becomes generator template. |
| B3 | PC-as-NPC unified spec | story | high | 3 | A7 | Unified spec: starting knowledge graph, starting relationship map, reverse knowledge (bidirectional), orientation monologue, agency boundaries, authored relationship stubs, tell inversion. 9-step conversion checklist. |
| B4 | Smuggler voice card + moral arc spec | story | high | 3 | A7 | Two deliverables: (1) Smuggler voice card — paired examples with detective showing dual-lens register differences. (2) Smuggler moral arc — 4 phases (Comfort→Doubt→Reckoning→Compromise), smuggler-specific FactIds, monologue triggers. Subsumes #310 scope. |
| B5 | NPC-format briefs for both PCs — Concept A v0.1 | story | high | 4 | B3 | NPC-mode behavior scripts (5-7 routine entries each), reverse dual-lens notes, observation monologue (3-5 lines per character). ~20-30 authored items total. |
### Group C: Content Directory & Schema (split teams)
| ID | Title | Type | Priority | Sprint | Team | Blocked By | Description |
|----|-------|------|----------|--------|------|------------|-------------|
| C1 | Content directory structure design doc | story | high | 3 | copy | — | Document converged structure: `_meta/` + `_schema/` (infrastructure), `global/` + `districts/` (content). Canonical_id format. Mod overlay mechanics. District as atomic pack unit. Informs all content implementation. |
| C2 | Create content/ directory skeleton | task | high | 3 | server | C1 | Create directory tree with empty YAML stubs. `_meta/`, `_schema/`, `global/` (factions, technology, contraband, knowledge, enums, regions), `districts/sova-transit/` (district.yaml, npcs/, locations/, templates/, triangles/, lines/). |
| C3 | Content schema definitions (YAML Schema files) | story | high | 3 | server | C1 | Create `_schema/` with validation schemas: npc.schema.yaml (tier-conditional), location, faction, template, fact, dialogue, monologue, district, pool. |
| C4 | Create global/enums/ YAML files from D-035 | task | medium | 4 | server | C2 | Populate enums: situations (13), topics (9), moods (8), triggers (9), access-tiers (5), activities (new). |
| C5 | Create global/knowledge/entity-attributes.yaml | task | medium | 4 | server | C2 | Machine-readable entity attribute definitions. 14 detective + smuggler keys (count depends on D-03 resolution). |
| C6 | Create pools.yaml for v0.1 seed-time selection | task | medium | 4 | server | C2 | Sova single-candidate pools: friend_smuggler, friend_detective, bar_regulars, compromised_inspector, primary_contraband. Architecture supports N candidates. |
| C7 | Create template YAML files with role slot definitions | task | medium | 4 | server | C2 | 3 social sites: logistics-hub.yaml, bar.yaml, smuggling-ring.yaml. Role slots with count ranges, required flags, pool references, triangle constraints. |
| C8 | Create triangle YAML files for 5 v0.1 triangles | task | medium | 4 | server | C2 | 5 triangles. Self-contained forks (no cross-triangle cascade per A-17). Includes updated T1 with Volume Escalation. |
| C9 | Implement make validate-content CLI | story | high | 4 | server | C3 | Structural + tier-conditional validation. Reads _schema/, validates all YAML. v0.2: cross-reference validation. |
| C10 | Pre-commit FactId typo check | task | medium | 4 | ci | — | Grep-based pre-commit check validating FactId references against canonical facts.yaml. |
### Group D: Design Specs
| ID | Title | Type | Priority | Sprint | Team | Blocked By | Description |
|----|-------|------|----------|--------|------|------------|-------------|
| D2 | Seed configuration schema design | story | medium | 4 | server | — | Schema for what the randomizer produces at game-start: FRIEND selections, social site population, compromised NPC, contraband type. v0.1 has single-candidate pools but architecture must support N. |
| D4 | News ticker headline pool | task | medium | 4 | copy | — | ~20 dual-lens headlines for Meridian feed at Lera's. Freight data, politics, local infrastructure, sports, Commission advisories. Each works as dual-lens monologue trigger. |
### Group NEW: Tickets from Round 1 + Round 2
| ID | Title | Type | Priority | Sprint | Team | Blocked By | Description |
|----|-------|------|----------|--------|------|------------|-------------|
| NEW-1 | Apply Gestalt's NPC pattern/motivation mapping | task | high | 3 | copy | — | Apply the canonical v0.1 mapping (Gestalt's Round 2 finalized table) to wiki and content files. 17 NPCs × (pattern + motivation). Includes Harek's structural role per Paula Gap 7. |
| NEW-2 | Drin Tier 2 profile expansion | task | medium | 3 | copy | NEW-1 | Drin confirmed Tier 2 (A-01). Expand wiki profile to full Tier 2 depth: all 10 profile axes, smuggler lens section, triangle membership formalized. |
| NEW-3 | Wiki → YAML content conversion (Sova NPCs) | story | high | 4 | copy | C1, C2, C3 | Convert 17 NPC wiki profiles to engine-readable YAML. Includes routine YAML layer (Paula Gap 3), triangle fork decision points (Gap 4), location smuggler detail (Gap 6). Tyre estimates 2-3 days. |
| NEW-4 | Monologue content pool — minimum viable (~200 lines) | story | high | 4 | copy | #261, B4 | ~100 lines per character. Categories: arrival observations, NPC routine commentary, environmental flavor, contradiction hints, idle reflections, tutorial/orientation. Follows Mellanie's authoring order (FRIEND packs first, then fill). |
| NEW-5 | v0.1 wow moment content checklist | task | high | 3 | copy | — | Map D-039's 6 wow moments to specific content deliverables + implementation tickets. Track completion. Acceptance: every moment has identified content + code backing it. |
| NEW-6 | PC-as-NPC content authoring | story | high | 5 | copy | B3, B5 | Author the actual lines: 5-7 routine entries per character, 3-5 observation monologue lines, reverse dual-lens notes. ~25 authored items (Mellanie's budget). |
| NEW-7 | v0.1 interaction verb spec | task | medium | 3 | copy | — | Document the 7 interaction types (A-04: Move, Look, Monologue, Examine Object, Examine NPC, Talk, Overhear). Define triggers, UI needs, server events per type. v0.1 surfaces single context-sensitive action; architecture supports N verbs. |
### Group NEW-R2: Tickets from Lead's Round 2 Decisions
| ID | Title | Type | Priority | Sprint | Team | Blocked By | Description |
|----|-------|------|----------|--------|------|------------|-------------|
| NEW-8 | YAML → RON converter tool | task | medium | 4 | server | C1 | Build-time converter: reads content YAML, emits RON. Lives in `tooling/`. Runs as make target (`make content-ron`). Not on critical path — engine consumes YAML in v0.1; RON is future-proofing. |
| NEW-9 | Multi-verb interaction architecture — server InteractionOptions | story | high | 3 | server | — | Server models N available actions per entity via `InteractionOptions` component. v0.1 client picks first/best; v0.2 client shows menu. Must not be throwaway. Includes ObserverSnapshot v3 extension for interaction data. |
| NEW-10 | Multi-verb interaction architecture — client extensible prompt | story | high | 3 | client | NEW-9 | Client-side interaction prompt designed for extensibility. v0.1: single context-sensitive E prompt. Architecture supports v0.2 multi-verb menu. Prompt system reads InteractionOptions from server state. |
| NEW-11 | Pause system — server tick rate scaling | story | medium | 3 | server | — | Tick rate supports 3 states: full speed (normal play), 50% speed (UI overlay open), 0% (spacebar pause). Server receives pause/speed commands from client. |
| NEW-12 | Pause system — client state machine | story | medium | 3 | client | NEW-11 | Client pause state machine: Normal → Overlay (50% speed, triggered by knowledge panel / dialogue) → Paused (spacebar from any state). Spacebar always overrides to full pause. |
| NEW-13 | Line previewer CLI | task | medium | 4 | server | C3, C9 | CLI tool to preview monologue/dialogue line selection for a given game state. Tyre's recommendation for content tuning. Lives in `tooling/`. Helps content authors test prerequisite logic without running the full game. |
---
## 5. Sprint Plan
### Sprint 3: Know (Copy Team — Content Foundation)
**Goal:** Deliver the content specs and wiki fixes that unblock server implementation and content authoring.
| Priority | Ticket | Title | Owner Hint | Effort |
|----------|--------|-------|------------|--------|
| **P0** | **#261** | **Dual Lens Authoring Guide** | **Paula** | **Large** |
| **P0** | **C1** | **Content directory structure design** | **Tyre/Gestalt** | **Medium** |
| P0 | A1 | Apply canonical full names | Paula | Small |
| P0 | A2 | Hael → Naia Tamm rename | Paula | Small |
| P0 | A7 | Smuggler entity attributes | Paula | Small |
| P1 | B2 | MIRROR pattern spec | Gestalt/Gore | Medium |
| P1 | B4 | Smuggler voice + moral arc (subsumes #310) | Gore/Mellanie | Medium |
| P1 | NEW-1 | Apply Gestalt's NPC pattern mapping | Gestalt | Small |
| P1 | NEW-5 | Wow moment content checklist | SI | Small |
| P1 | A10 | Nils Davan stub | Paula | Small |
| P1 | A11 | Triangle 1 fix | Gestalt/Paula | Medium |
| P2 | B3 | PC-as-NPC spec | Gestalt/Paula | Medium |
| P2 | A8 | Shortcode fix | Mellanie | Small |
| P2 | NEW-2 | Drin Tier 2 profile expansion | Paula | Small |
| P2 | NEW-7 | Interaction verb spec | Gestalt | Small |
**Sprint 3 copy total: 15 tickets (2 P0, 6 P1, 5 P2, 2 small enough to parallelize)**
### Sprint 3: Know (Server Team — Content-Adjacent, Proposed Additions)
| Priority | Ticket | Title | Effort |
|----------|--------|-------|--------|
| P1 | C2 | Create content/ directory skeleton | Small |
| P1 | C3 | Content schema definitions | Medium |
| P1 | NEW-9 | Multi-verb interaction architecture — InteractionOptions | Medium |
| P2 | NEW-11 | Pause system — tick rate scaling | Small |
### Sprint 3: Know (Client Team — Proposed Additions)
| Priority | Ticket | Title | Effort |
|----------|--------|-------|--------|
| P1 | NEW-10 | Multi-verb interaction — extensible prompt | Medium |
| P2 | NEW-12 | Pause system — client state machine | Small |
### Sprint 4 (Content Conversion + Authoring Begins)
| Ticket | Title | Team | Blocked By |
|--------|-------|------|------------|
| NEW-3 | Wiki → YAML conversion (17 NPCs) | copy | C1, C2, C3 |
| C4 | Enum YAMLs from D-035 | server | C2 |
| C5 | Entity-attributes YAML | server | C2 |
| C6 | Pools YAML | server | C2 |
| C7 | Social site template YAMLs | server | C2 |
| C8 | Triangle YAMLs | server | C2 |
| C9 | validate-content CLI | server | C3 |
| C10 | Pre-commit FactId check | ci | — |
| A6 | Smuggler FactId progression text | copy | B4 |
| A12 | Environmental text examples | copy | A3/#319 |
| B5 | PC NPC-format briefs | copy | B3 |
| D4 | News ticker headlines (~20) | copy | — |
| #306 | News ticker content (align with D4) | copy | — |
| D2 | Seed configuration schema | server | — |
| NEW-8 | YAML → RON converter | server | C1 |
| NEW-13 | Line previewer CLI | server | C3, C9 |
| #326 | YAML content loader | server | C1, C2 |
| A3/#319 | Krenn brief + seed.yaml reference | copy | — |
### Sprint 5+ (Content at Scale)
| Ticket | Title | Team | Blocked By |
|--------|-------|------|------------|
| NEW-4 | Monologue content pool (~200 lines) | copy | #261, B4 |
| NEW-6 | PC-as-NPC content authoring (~25 items) | copy | B3, B5 |
| B1 | NPC Authoring Style Guide (generator spec) | copy | A3, A4, A7, B2, B4 |
| A4 | Regional style guide / seed.yaml template | copy | — |
| A9 | Thematic Question field (Tier 1 profiles) | copy | B2 |
| #297 | THE FRIEND: Kael content pack | copy | #261 |
| #298 | THE FRIEND: Sera content pack | copy | #261 |
| #190 | Workplace content pack | copy | #261 |
| #191 | Bar content pack | copy | #261 |
| #192 | Smuggling ring content pack | copy | #261 |
---
## 6. Revised Dependency Chain
```
SPRINT 3 — Two Parallel Critical Chains
========================================
Chain 1: Content Authoring Pipeline
------------------------------------
#261 (Dual Lens Guide) [P0, CRITICAL PATH ROOT]
├── blocks B4 (Smuggler voice + moral arc) [Sprint 3]
│ ├── blocks A6 (Smuggler FactId text) [Sprint 4]
│ └── blocks NEW-4 (Monologue pool) [Sprint 5]
├── blocks #297 (FRIEND: Kael) [Sprint 5]
├── blocks #298 (FRIEND: Sera) [Sprint 5]
├── blocks #299 (Opening hook: smuggler) [Sprint 5]
├── blocks #300 (Opening hook: detective) [Sprint 5]
└── blocks #190, #191, #192 (Content packs) [Sprint 5]
A7 (Smuggler attributes) [P0, Sprint 3]
├── blocks B4 (Smuggler voice) [Sprint 3]
└── blocks B3 (PC-as-NPC spec) [Sprint 3]
└── blocks B5 (PC briefs) [Sprint 4]
└── blocks NEW-6 (PC-as-NPC authoring) [Sprint 5]
Chain 2: Content Architecture Pipeline
---------------------------------------
C1 (Content dir design) [P0, Sprint 3]
├── blocks C2 (skeleton) [Sprint 3, server]
│ ├── blocks C4 (enums) [Sprint 4]
│ ├── blocks C5 (entity attrs) [Sprint 4]
│ ├── blocks C6 (pools) [Sprint 4]
│ ├── blocks C7 (templates) [Sprint 4]
│ ├── blocks C8 (triangles) [Sprint 4]
│ ├── blocks NEW-3 (wiki→YAML) [Sprint 4]
│ └── blocks #326 (YAML loader) [Sprint 4]
├── blocks C3 (schemas) [Sprint 3, server]
│ ├── blocks C9 (validator) [Sprint 4]
│ ├── blocks NEW-3 (wiki→YAML) [Sprint 4]
│ └── blocks NEW-13 (line previewer) [Sprint 4]
└── blocks NEW-8 (RON converter) [Sprint 4]
Independent Chains (Sprint 3)
------------------------------
B2 (MIRROR spec) → A9 (Thematic Question) [Sprint 4]
A10 (Nils stub) → A11 (Triangle 1 fix) [Sprint 3]
NEW-9 (InteractionOptions, server) → NEW-10 (Extensible prompt, client) [Sprint 3]
NEW-11 (Tick rate scaling, server) → NEW-12 (Pause state machine, client) [Sprint 3]
```
---
## 7. Ticket Count Summary
| Category | Count | Teams |
|----------|-------|-------|
| Wiki fixes (A-series) | 8 | copy |
| Style guides & specs (B-series) | 5 | copy |
| Content directory & schema (C-series) | 10 | copy (1), server (8), ci (1) |
| Design specs (D-series) | 2 | server (1), copy (1) |
| Round 1 new tickets (NEW 1-7) | 7 | copy |
| Round 2 new tickets (NEW 8-13) | 6 | server (4), client (2) |
| **Total new tickets** | **38** | copy (21), server (13), client (2), ci (1), + 1 epic update |
| Existing ticket updates | 10 | — |
**Delta from Round 1:** +6 tickets (NEW-8 through NEW-13 from lead decisions), +2 server Sprint 3 additions (NEW-9, NEW-11), +2 client Sprint 3 additions (NEW-10, NEW-12). Removed: D3 (killed), A5 (deferred), D1 (deferred). Merged: A3 into #319, #310 into B4.
---
## 8. Risks & Recommendations
**Risk 1: #261 is still the critical path root.** Every content authoring ticket flows through it. If it slips even one sprint, the entire content pipeline delays. Recommend: assign Paula immediately, time-box to 5 working days, accept "good enough" over "perfect."
**Risk 2: Sprint 3 copy team has 15 tickets.** That's a lot. But 7 are small tasks (A1, A2, A7, A8, A10, NEW-1, NEW-2) that can be parallelized. The real load is #261, C1, B2, B4, and A11. Recommend: Paula owns #261 + wiki fixes (A1, A2, A7, A10, NEW-2). Gestalt owns C1, NEW-1, B2, A11, NEW-7. Mellanie owns A8, B4. SI owns NEW-5.
**Risk 3: Server team Sprint 3 is already heavy** (10 existing tickets). Adding C2, C3, NEW-9, NEW-11 is +4. Recommend: C2 and C3 are blocked by C1 anyway — they can start mid-sprint when C1 lands. NEW-9 and NEW-11 are independent and can begin immediately.
**Risk 4: Content conversion (NEW-3) is a Sprint 4 bottleneck.** Tyre estimates 2-3 full days for 17 NPC conversions. This blocks the server from testing with real data. Recommend: start with the 3 Tier 1 NPCs (Kael, Sera, Naia) as soon as C2 lands, don't wait for all 17.
---
*Proposals only — no tickets created. Awaiting lead approval.*
*Compiled by SI. Source: Round 1 tracking doc (Qatux), all 7 Round 1 responses, lead Round 2 decisions.*