jpmschweitzer/settled-reach
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

data(economics): #1016 cultural-write pass + 47-value heritage migration #147

Closed
jpmschweitzer wants to merge 0 commits from cultural-specialization-pass into main
pull from: cultural-specialization-pass
merge into: :main
Conversation 1 Commits - Files Changed -
jpmschweitzer commented 2026-06-03 10:11:52 +02:00
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

Summary

Completes the deferred cultural half of #1016 and migrates the heritage
vocabulary to the canonical 47-value taxonomy (D-237). Every system whose
founders diverge from their corridor baseline now reads as itself instead of
defaulting to the corridor's dominant culture.

Migration (mechanical)

  • _CULTURAL_HERITAGE replaced with the canonical 47-value set
    (docs/workshops/system-economic-specialization/heritage-taxonomy-draft.md).
  • 4 shipped hero values renamed to canonical: afrikaans_cape→afrikaans,
    french_provencal→french, italian_northern→italian,
    norse_compact→nordic.

Content pass

Authored via a 6-sector Miri fan-out — one worldbuilder agent per sector
(core / north / south / west / east / deep-frontier) ran the D-237 4-step
heritage triage (system name → feature/corp names → GTTR founding mention →
corridor fallback) over its systems and returned evidence-grounded pins.

Reconciled through a validation gate: every proposed system_id checked
against star_systems, every token against the heritage+activity vocabulary.
The gate caught one transcription artifact (GJ 333 → the real Groenland is
GJ 3333) and zero bad tokens before anything was written.

Result: cultural coverage 32 → 171 pins, 54 distinct values. Pinned only
where founding heritage diverges from the corridor baseline (D-167/D-232);
corridor-typical systems left NULL → corridor default.

Distribution (balanced — afrikaans no longer dominant, post-#1019)

portuguese 15 · german 12 · vietnamese 10 · afrikaans 10
scottish 7 · nordic 7 · korean 7 · institutional 6
zulu 5 · spanish 5 · french 5 · finnish 5 · japanese 4 · chinese 4 · …
arab 3 · persian 2 · turkic 1
+ long tail: welsh, herero, czech, akan, hungarian, konkan, afro_brazilian,
  cape_verdean, shona, angolan, sao_tomean, bengali, indian, irish,
  luxembourgish, canarian, brazilian, punjabi, polish, swahili, igbo, tagalog,
  maori, dutch, xhosa, cape_malay …

Judgment calls (flagged for review)

  • Kruger 60 + Pedra Seca → xhosa — both mixed South-African founding;
    used xhosa to add diversity rather than re-inflate afrikaans. Pedra Seca
    has a Portuguese name but Afrikaans/Xhosa GTTR founders     — a real
    name/heritage mismatch, noted for a future content fix (not papered over).
  • Kampala Gate / Moyale / Mwangaza → swahili — nearest available token
    for East-African-interior heritage (Baganda / Kenyan / Ethiopian); the
    taxonomy has no dedicated value, a candidate future addition.
  • Kept hero pins Kensho=scholarly, Keid=scholarly,
    Nyrheim=nordic (respecting the taxonomy's norse_compact→nordic
    split rather than re-reading it as compact_cooperative).
  • Altmark cosmopolitan→financial_technocratic (GTTR = financial hub).

Verification

make regen-db clean · V-SES-04 passes (all 171 values canonical) · no
duplicate TOML stanzas · meta stamp fresh · ruff clean · pre-push gates green.
Agent evidence spot-checked against gttr_hook (Kovács=Hungarian, Dalim=Arabic
star, Kumasi=Asante/Akan, Dzimbahwe=Great-Zimbabwe/Shona) — grounded, not
fabricated.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

## Summary Completes the deferred **cultural half of #1016** and migrates the heritage vocabulary to the canonical **47-value taxonomy** (D-237). Every system whose founders diverge from their corridor baseline now reads as itself instead of defaulting to the corridor's dominant culture. ## Migration (mechanical) - `_CULTURAL_HERITAGE` replaced with the canonical 47-value set (`docs/workshops/system-economic-specialization/heritage-taxonomy-draft.md`). - 4 shipped hero values renamed to canonical: `afrikaans_cape`→`afrikaans`, `french_provencal`→`french`, `italian_northern`→`italian`, `norse_compact`→`nordic`. ## Content pass Authored via a **6-sector Miri fan-out** — one worldbuilder agent per sector (core / north / south / west / east / deep-frontier) ran the D-237 4-step heritage triage (system name → feature/corp names → GTTR founding mention → corridor fallback) over its systems and returned evidence-grounded pins. Reconciled through a **validation gate**: every proposed `system_id` checked against `star_systems`, every token against the heritage+activity vocabulary. The gate caught one transcription artifact (`GJ 333` → the real Groenland is `GJ 3333`) and zero bad tokens before anything was written. Result: **cultural coverage 32 → 171 pins, 54 distinct values.** Pinned only where founding heritage **diverges** from the corridor baseline (D-167/D-232); corridor-typical systems left NULL → corridor default. ### Distribution (balanced — afrikaans no longer dominant, post-#1019) ``` portuguese 15 · german 12 · vietnamese 10 · afrikaans 10 scottish 7 · nordic 7 · korean 7 · institutional 6 zulu 5 · spanish 5 · french 5 · finnish 5 · japanese 4 · chinese 4 · … arab 3 · persian 2 · turkic 1 + long tail: welsh, herero, czech, akan, hungarian, konkan, afro_brazilian, cape_verdean, shona, angolan, sao_tomean, bengali, indian, irish, luxembourgish, canarian, brazilian, punjabi, polish, swahili, igbo, tagalog, maori, dutch, xhosa, cape_malay … ``` ## Judgment calls (flagged for review) - **Kruger 60 + Pedra Seca → `xhosa`** — both mixed South-African founding; used `xhosa` to add diversity rather than re-inflate afrikaans. **Pedra Seca has a Portuguese *name* but Afrikaans/Xhosa GTTR *founders*** — a real name/heritage mismatch, noted for a future content fix (not papered over). - **Kampala Gate / Moyale / Mwangaza → `swahili`** — nearest available token for East-African-*interior* heritage (Baganda / Kenyan / Ethiopian); the taxonomy has no dedicated value, a candidate future addition. - Kept hero pins **Kensho=`scholarly`**, **Keid=`scholarly`**, **Nyrheim=`nordic`** (respecting the taxonomy's `norse_compact`→`nordic` split rather than re-reading it as `compact_cooperative`). - **Altmark** `cosmopolitan`→`financial_technocratic` (GTTR = financial hub). ## Verification `make regen-db` clean · V-SES-04 passes (all 171 values canonical) · no duplicate TOML stanzas · meta stamp fresh · ruff clean · pre-push gates green. Agent evidence spot-checked against `gttr_hook` (Kovács=Hungarian, Dalim=Arabic star, Kumasi=Asante/Akan, Dzimbahwe=Great-Zimbabwe/Shona) — grounded, not fabricated. 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)
jpmschweitzer added 2 commits 2026-06-03 10:11:52 +02:00
data(economics): #1016 cultural-write pass + canonical 47-value heritage migration 21793c1a94 
Completes the deferred cultural half of #1016 and migrates the heritage
vocabulary to the canonical 47-value taxonomy (D-237).

Migration (mechanical):
- _CULTURAL_HERITAGE replaced with the canonical 47-value set
  (docs/.../heritage-taxonomy-draft.md). Renamed the 4 shipped hero
  values to canonical: afrikaans_cape->afrikaans, french_provencal->
  french, italian_northern->italian, norse_compact->nordic.

Content pass (authored from GTTR/name heritage triage, 6-sector fan-out):
- +139 new cultural_specialization pins and 1 change (Altmark
  cosmopolitan->financial_technocratic), taking coverage 32 -> 171
  across 54 distinct values. Each pin is grounded in an explicit GTTR
  founding-community statement or system/feature name etymology, applied
  only where founding heritage DIVERGES from the corridor baseline
  (D-167/D-232); corridor-typical systems left NULL.

Distribution is now balanced and diverse — portuguese 15, german 12,
vietnamese 10, afrikaans 10 (no longer dominant post-#1019), then a long
tail filling the previously-missing slots (welsh, herero, czech, akan,
hungarian, konkan, afro_brazilian, cape_verdean, shona, arab/persian/
turkic, etc.).

Judgment calls (flagged for review):
- Kruger 60 + Pedra Seca -> xhosa (mixed SA founding; adds diversity).
  Pedra Seca has a Portuguese name but Afrikaans/Xhosa GTTR founding —
  name/heritage mismatch noted for a future content fix.
- Kampala Gate / Moyale / Mwangaza -> swahili as the nearest token for
  East-African-interior heritage; taxonomy may want a dedicated value.
- Kept hero pins Kensho=scholarly, Keid=scholarly, Nyrheim=nordic.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
chore(meta): update changelog 9e791240c5 
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
jpmschweitzer added 1 commit 2026-06-03 10:23:53 +02:00
data(economics): address PR #147 review — fused/activity pin fixes 00c8574e11 
Review fixes for the #1016 cultural pass (Hoshe/Paula/Miri):

- Kruger 60 (GJ 860A) xhosa -> cosmopolitan (Miri): GTTR describes an
  Afrikaner/Xhosa/Zulu founding "without mapping cleanly onto any of
  them" — the textbook genuinely-fused case, which taxonomy rule 4
  resolves to cosmopolitan rather than one of the three. Commented.
- Altmark (GJ 357) financial_technocratic -> cosmopolitan (Paula):
  reverts to the original shipped value; the GTTR reads as commercial
  non-alignment, not credential-based technocracy.
- Kampala Gate (GJ 667B) + Moyale (GJ 1292) keep swahili but add inline
  comments documenting that these are East-African-INTERIOR founders
  (Baganda; Kenyan/Ethiopian Borana-Oromo) for which the taxonomy has no
  dedicated token — swahili is the nearest available, NULL would fall to
  the wrong corridor default. Gap logged for a follow-up taxonomy value.
  Mwangaza (693) swahili is literally correct (coastal) — untouched.
- heritage-taxonomy-draft.md: stale "(38)" subheadings -> "(47)" to match
  the actual canonical count (Hoshe/Miri doc typo).

Retracted: Pedra Seca (GJ 421B) xhosa — reviewer thought it lacked
authored backing, but its gttr.md explicitly states "Afrikaans and Xhosa
heritage"; pin kept.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
jpmschweitzer commented 2026-06-03 10:24:14 +02:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link
Copy Source

Review — PR #147 (copy: #1016 cultural-write pass + 47-value migration)

Multi-agent review (Hoshe / Paula / Miri).

Reviewer Focus Verdict
Hoshe QA / integrity APPROVE
Paula Cultural depth APPROVE (w/ comments)
Miri World consistency APPROVE (w/ comments)

Verdict: APPROVED. All actionable comments addressed in 00c8574e1.

Hoshe (QA) — clean

All 171 values are a strict subset of the canonical 47 heritage + 12 activity sets (no unknown tokens). 4 hero renames applied, no old forms survive. TOML parses; no duplicate stanzas or duplicate keys. 14-system spot-check confirms pins are grounded in gttr_hook (Kovács→hungarian, Dalim→arab, Velha Guarda→cape_verdean, Pemberton→welsh, Ngata's Star→maori, …). No baseline-redundancy violations.

Findings & resolutions

# Reviewer Finding Resolution
1 Miri Kruger 60 (GJ 860A) xhosa — GTTR says the Afrikaner/Xhosa/Zulu founding maps "cleanly onto none of them" (genuinely fused) Fixed — → cosmopolitan (taxonomy rule 4), with a comment
2 Paula Altmark (GJ 357) financial_technocratic reads as technocracy; GTTR is commercial non-alignment Fixed — reverted to original cosmopolitan
3 Paula (HIGH) / Miri Kampala Gate (667B) + Moyale (1292) swahili flattens East-African-interior peoples (Baganda; Kenyan/Ethiopian) onto a coastal token Documented — kept swahili (nearest token; NULL → wrong anglo corridor default), added inline TOML comments + logged a taxonomy-gap follow-up. Mwangaza (693) swahili is literally correct (coastal) — untouched
4 Hoshe / Miri heritage-taxonomy-draft.md subheadings say "(38)" but the set is 47 Fixed — 4 subheadings → "(47)"
5 Paula (MED) Pedra Seca (421B) xhosa — "no wiki file, unjustified pin" Retracted — its gttr.md explicitly states "Afrikaans and Xhosa heritage" (reviewer read the wrong path); pin kept

Left as-is (cosmetic, defensible): Knotenpunkt=german (German name in deep-frontier = divergent), Einde=afrikaans (name is Afrikaans/Dutch; fits the Cairn-pocket cluster).

Verified after fixes

make regen-db clean · V-SES-04 passes (171 values, all canonical) · stamp fresh · pre-push gates green.

Follow-up logged: the taxonomy would benefit from an East-African-interior heritage value (Great Lakes / Horn) so Kampala Gate & Moyale needn't borrow swahili — candidate for the next taxonomy revision.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

## Review — PR #147 (copy: #1016 cultural-write pass + 47-value migration) Multi-agent review (Hoshe / Paula / Miri). | Reviewer | Focus | Verdict | |---|---|---| | Hoshe | QA / integrity | APPROVE | | Paula | Cultural depth | APPROVE (w/ comments) | | Miri | World consistency | APPROVE (w/ comments) | **Verdict: APPROVED.** All actionable comments addressed in `00c8574e1`. ### Hoshe (QA) — clean All 171 values are a strict subset of the canonical 47 heritage + 12 activity sets (no unknown tokens). 4 hero renames applied, no old forms survive. TOML parses; no duplicate stanzas or duplicate keys. 14-system spot-check confirms pins are grounded in `gttr_hook` (Kovács→hungarian, Dalim→arab, Velha Guarda→cape_verdean, Pemberton→welsh, Ngata's Star→maori, …). No baseline-redundancy violations. ### Findings & resolutions | # | Reviewer | Finding | Resolution | |---|----------|---------|------------| | 1 | Miri | Kruger 60 (GJ 860A) `xhosa` — GTTR says the Afrikaner/Xhosa/Zulu founding maps "cleanly onto none of them" (genuinely fused) | **Fixed** — → `cosmopolitan` (taxonomy rule 4), with a comment | | 2 | Paula | Altmark (GJ 357) `financial_technocratic` reads as technocracy; GTTR is commercial non-alignment | **Fixed** — reverted to original `cosmopolitan` | | 3 | Paula (HIGH) / Miri | Kampala Gate (667B) + Moyale (1292) `swahili` flattens East-African-*interior* peoples (Baganda; Kenyan/Ethiopian) onto a coastal token | **Documented** — kept `swahili` (nearest token; NULL → wrong *anglo* corridor default), added inline TOML comments + logged a taxonomy-gap follow-up. Mwangaza (693) `swahili` is literally correct (coastal) — untouched | | 4 | Hoshe / Miri | `heritage-taxonomy-draft.md` subheadings say "(38)" but the set is 47 | **Fixed** — 4 subheadings → "(47)" | | 5 | Paula (MED) | Pedra Seca (421B) `xhosa` — "no wiki file, unjustified pin" | **Retracted** — its `gttr.md` explicitly states "Afrikaans and Xhosa heritage" (reviewer read the wrong path); pin kept | **Left as-is (cosmetic, defensible):** Knotenpunkt=`german` (German name in deep-frontier = divergent), Einde=`afrikaans` (name is Afrikaans/Dutch; fits the Cairn-pocket cluster). ### Verified after fixes `make regen-db` clean · V-SES-04 passes (171 values, all canonical) · stamp fresh · pre-push gates green. Follow-up logged: the taxonomy would benefit from an **East-African-interior** heritage value (Great Lakes / Horn) so Kampala Gate & Moyale needn't borrow `swahili` — candidate for the next taxonomy revision. 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)
jpmschweitzer closed this pull request 2026-06-03 10:25:47 +02:00

Pull request closed

This pull request cannot be reopened because the branch was deleted.
Sign in to join this conversation.
Reviewers
No Reviewers
Labels
No items
No labels
Milestone
No items
No Milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No projects
Assignees
Clear assignees
jpmschweitzer (Jeroen Schweitzer)
No Assignees
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: jpmschweitzer/settled-reach#147