atlas-update-field: update system-level fields across star_systems,
system_gates, and system_history tables with field whitelist.
atlas-commit-and-sync: full per-system pipeline (verify → wipe → commit
→ sync-wiki → git commit). Updated atlas SKILL.md with new commands.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Wiki header star type mismatches proposal/System Profile. GJ682 and GJ3728B missing Calibration Note acknowledgment
2
tooling/atlas-commit-and-sync:33
warning
Shell injection vector — $FILE interpolated into python string. Fix with heredoc/sys.argv
3
wiki/GJ-667C/index.md
suggestion
Non-standard header format (raw spectral class, middle-dot separator)
4
16 wiki pages
suggestion
Inconsistent header star type formats inherited from stubs
Paula (Narrative Depth): REQUEST_CHANGES
The wiki content is a massive quality leap — Supply Dependency, Faction Notes, Silence Topics, Narrative Hooks are genuinely strong. Best worldbuilding prose in the project. Three blocking issues.
#
File
Severity
Issue
1
GJ687 (Matsue) + GJ860B (Changwon)
critical
Japanese 5:0→6:0, Korean 6:0→7:0 confirm:subvert ratio. No subversions added. Requires at least one subverting system per group
2
GJ625 (Songjiang) wiki
warning
Header K-type contradicts READ-ONLY M2 Star field. Author-declared "convention" is not established policy
3
GJ687 (Matsue) wiki
warning
systems.db says unsettled but wiki asserts 800K pop. Data correction ticket needed before merge
4
GJ53A (Bridgepoint) wiki
suggestion
English name treated as culturally neutral — inconsistent with how all other heritage naming handled
5
GJ667C wiki
suggestion
Narrative Hook restates Silence Topic instead of providing discoverable symptom
All 6 targeted header fixes verified. Injection vector fixed. GJ625 M2→M2V confirmed. Unfixed headers (GJ541, GJ79) documented with Calibration Notes. Stale Calibration Notes on 3 pages — ticketed as #754.
Paula (Narrative Depth): APPROVE (revised)
Revised stereotype count after careful re-read: Japanese ~3:1 (not 6:0), Korean ~4:1 (not 7:0) — subversions exist (Shimanami, Seongho). Stereotype ratio tracking deferred to post-atlas completion audit. GJ667C re-authoring resolved. GJ687 DB conflict documented at wiki layer. GJ625 stale Calibration Note ticketed (#754).
Miri (World Consistency): APPROVE
All fixes verified. GJ667C triple-star note present. GJ53A confirmed single G-type. GJ432A wiki "Punjabi-Canadian" ticketed (#755). GJ541 header ticketed (#756).
Verdict: APPROVED
Remaining items tracked as tickets:
#754 — stale Calibration Notes (GJ1128, GJ136, GJ625)
#755 — GJ432A wiki "Punjabi-Canadian" one-line fix
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.
Summary
atlas-update-field(DB field updates),atlas-commit-and-sync(single-system commit pipeline)Review notes
tooling/atlas-verifyTest plan
tooling/atlas-verify docs/atlas/proposals/*.json— all pass🤖 Generated with Claude Code
Review: copy -> main (type: copy) — PR #102
Hoshe (QA): REQUEST_CHANGES
All 47 proposals pass atlas-verify.
population: nullis clean across Track C. Schema consistent. Two medium issues.$FILEinterpolated into python string. Fix with heredoc/sys.argvPaula (Narrative Depth): REQUEST_CHANGES
The wiki content is a massive quality leap — Supply Dependency, Faction Notes, Silence Topics, Narrative Hooks are genuinely strong. Best worldbuilding prose in the project. Three blocking issues.
K-typecontradicts READ-ONLYM2Star field. Author-declared "convention" is not established policyunsettledbut wiki asserts 800K pop. Data correction ticket needed before mergeMiri (World Consistency): REQUEST_CHANGES
Cultural corridor identity well-executed. Tidal locking correct. Haodu 2.8B justified. Some data mismatches and a missing triple-star context.
Verdict: CHANGES REQUESTED
Convergence across reviewers:
Review: copy -> main (type: copy) — PR #102, Round 2
Hoshe (QA): APPROVE
All 6 targeted header fixes verified. Injection vector fixed. GJ625 M2→M2V confirmed. Unfixed headers (GJ541, GJ79) documented with Calibration Notes. Stale Calibration Notes on 3 pages — ticketed as #754.
Paula (Narrative Depth): APPROVE (revised)
Revised stereotype count after careful re-read: Japanese ~3:1 (not 6:0), Korean ~4:1 (not 7:0) — subversions exist (Shimanami, Seongho). Stereotype ratio tracking deferred to post-atlas completion audit. GJ667C re-authoring resolved. GJ687 DB conflict documented at wiki layer. GJ625 stale Calibration Note ticketed (#754).
Miri (World Consistency): APPROVE
All fixes verified. GJ667C triple-star note present. GJ53A confirmed single G-type. GJ432A wiki "Punjabi-Canadian" ticketed (#755). GJ541 header ticketed (#756).
Verdict: APPROVED
Remaining items tracked as tickets:
Pull request closed