# Test Plan: Sprint 33 — Pecunia (Economics Simulation) - **Sprint:** 33 - **Date:** 2026-04-07 - **Author:** Hoshe (QA) - **Branch:** `sprint-33/server` - **Tickets:** #813, #805, #806, #807, #808, #809 - **Key spec:** `decisions/economics.md` (D-171–D-187), D-179 (stability acceptance criteria) --- ## How to Use This Document Verification queries are written for `tooling/db/sqlite-query`. Stability tests run via `tooling/econ-sim --stability-check` once #807 lands. All SQL queries assume a fully-imported `server/data/systems.db` (after running `make economy-db`). **Pass/fail convention:** Each test has an **Expected** clause. A test fails if the output deviates from Expected in any measurable way. Failures from #807 and later that involve oscillation or divergence indicate a broken model — tune α/β before calling it a feature (D-179). --- ## Pre-Flight: Baseline Data Sanity Run these before testing any ticket. If they fail, the DB state is corrupted and ticket-level tests are meaningless. ```sql -- BF-1: Commodity count must be 36 (D-184) SELECT COUNT(*) FROM commodities; -- Expected: 36 -- BF-2: Commodity tier breakdown must match D-184 (9/10/9/5/3) SELECT tier, COUNT(*) FROM commodities GROUP BY tier ORDER BY tier; -- Expected: -- intermediate 10 -- raw 9 -- final 9 -- service_professional 5 -- service_luxury 3 -- BF-3: Production chain count must be 21 (D-184) SELECT COUNT(*) FROM production_chains; -- Expected: 21 -- BF-4: Chain input count must be 40 (count inputs from production_chains.toml) SELECT COUNT(*) FROM chain_inputs; -- Expected: 40 -- BF-5: Gate links must be bidirectional (every from→to has a matching to→from) SELECT COUNT(*) FROM gate_links gl WHERE NOT EXISTS ( SELECT 1 FROM gate_links rev WHERE rev.from_system_id = gl.to_system_id AND rev.to_system_id = gl.from_system_id ); -- Expected: 0 -- BF-6: All chain inputs reference valid commodities SELECT COUNT(*) FROM chain_inputs ci LEFT JOIN commodities c ON ci.input_commodity_id = c.commodity_id WHERE c.commodity_id IS NULL; -- Expected: 0 -- BF-7: All chain outputs reference valid commodities SELECT COUNT(*) FROM production_chains pc LEFT JOIN commodities c ON pc.output_commodity_id = c.commodity_id WHERE c.commodity_id IS NULL; -- Expected: 0 ``` **Known discrepancy to verify:** The `commodities.toml` section header reads `# PROFESSIONAL SERVICES (7)` but only 5 entries follow. The total must be 36 (matching D-184: 9+10+9+5+3). Flag if the count is 38. --- ## #813 — Energy-over-gate Schema Extension **Spec ref:** D-186 **Assigned to:** Tyre **Status:** in_progress ### What was changed - `gate_energy_connected INTEGER DEFAULT 1` column added to `star_systems` (system-level, not per body/station — all nodes in a system inherit the system's setting via a join. Gate Corp energy is a system-wide commercial contract, not a per-node toggle.) - `MARK_PRIMARY` zones default to `false` (0) - All other zones default to `true` (1) - Migration is idempotent (safe to re-run via COLUMN_MIGRATIONS) - `set_gate_energy()` runs as step 6, after `set_currency_zones()` step 5 (correct ordering) ### Verification queries ```sql -- 813-1: Column exists on star_systems table PRAGMA table_info(star_systems); -- Expected: row with name='gate_energy_connected' and type='INTEGER' -- 813-2: MARK_PRIMARY systems have gate_energy_connected = 0 SELECT COUNT(*) FROM star_systems WHERE currency_zone = 'MARK_PRIMARY' AND gate_energy_connected != 0; -- Expected: 0 -- 813-3: TRACTUS_PRIMARY systems have gate_energy_connected = 1 SELECT COUNT(*) FROM star_systems WHERE currency_zone = 'TRACTUS_PRIMARY' AND gate_energy_connected != 1; -- Expected: 0 -- 813-4: MIXED systems have gate_energy_connected = 1 SELECT COUNT(*) FROM star_systems WHERE currency_zone = 'MIXED' AND gate_energy_connected != 1; -- Expected: 0 -- 813-5: gate_energy_connected is never NULL SELECT COUNT(*) FROM star_systems WHERE gate_energy_connected IS NULL; -- Expected: 0 -- 813-6: At least one MARK_PRIMARY system exists (validates zone data is present) SELECT COUNT(*) FROM star_systems WHERE currency_zone = 'MARK_PRIMARY'; -- Expected: > 0 (requires #820 copy work to be merged first; skip if copy branch not merged) -- 813-7: Sim binary can read gate_energy via join (integration spot-check) -- The sim must join bodies/stations to star_systems to get gate_energy_connected. -- Verify the join is correct: SELECT b.body_id, ss.gate_energy_connected FROM bodies b JOIN star_systems ss ON b.system_id = ss.system_id WHERE b.inhabited = 1 LIMIT 5; -- Expected: 5 rows with gate_energy_connected = 0 or 1 (not NULL) ``` ### Edge cases **813-E1: Idempotent migration** Run `make economy-db` twice on the same DB. Second run must not raise an error, and query 813-1 through 813-7 must still pass. **813-E2: Systems with NULL currency_zone** If any star system has `currency_zone IS NULL`, the migration logic must treat it as `TRACTUS_PRIMARY` (default to `true`). Verify no bodies end up with `gate_energy_connected = 0` due to a NULL zone. ```sql SELECT COUNT(*) FROM star_systems WHERE currency_zone IS NULL; -- Expected: 0 (import pipeline sets default; but verify regardless) ``` **813-E3: Demand reduction is NOT implemented here** Confirm the `~0.3× fusion_fuel` utility demand reduction is absent from the schema-only ticket. The demand model lives in the sim binary (#806). Verify: - No column named `utility_demand_modifier` or similar on star_systems - No new columns beyond `gate_energy_connected` on star_systems ### Regression markers - `tooling/economy-db/import_economics.py` migration block must still be idempotent - Existing BF-1 through BF-7 must still pass after #813 migration --- ## #805 — Corporation Pipeline and Validation **Spec ref:** D-175, D-182 **Assigned to:** Dudley **Status:** in_progress ### What was changed - `import_economics.py` (or a new companion script) reads `wiki/corporations/` markdown files - Populates `corp_presence` table from authored location data - Validates wiki corp names ↔ DB `corporations.proper_name` sync (D-182 sync constraint) - Coverage rules: 3+ corps per major commodity type, 1+ per inhabited system >100K pop - Chain completeness validation: every intermediate commodity has ≥1 producing chain - Coverage failures exit non-zero (D-175 phase gate) ### Verification queries ```sql -- 805-1: corp_presence is no longer empty after pipeline run SELECT COUNT(*) FROM corp_presence; -- Expected: > 0 -- 805-2: All corp_presence rows reference valid corp_id SELECT COUNT(*) FROM corp_presence cp LEFT JOIN corporations c ON cp.corp_id = c.corp_id WHERE c.corp_id IS NULL; -- Expected: 0 -- 805-3: All corp_presence rows reference valid location_id -- (either a body_id or station_id — location_type determines which table) SELECT COUNT(*) FROM corp_presence WHERE location_type = 'body' AND location_id NOT IN (SELECT body_id FROM bodies); -- Expected: 0 SELECT COUNT(*) FROM corp_presence WHERE location_type = 'station' AND location_id NOT IN (SELECT station_id FROM stations); -- Expected: 0 -- 805-4: Chain completeness — every intermediate must have a producing chain SELECT c.commodity_id, c.name FROM commodities c WHERE c.tier = 'intermediate' AND c.commodity_id NOT IN ( SELECT output_commodity_id FROM production_chains ); -- Expected: 0 rows (all 10 intermediates have a producing chain) -- 805-5: Chain completeness — every final good must have a producing chain SELECT c.commodity_id, c.name FROM commodities c WHERE c.tier = 'final' AND c.commodity_id NOT IN ( SELECT output_commodity_id FROM production_chains ); -- Expected: 0 rows (all 9 finals have a producing chain) -- 805-6: Services have NO producing chains (they are demand sinks, not outputs) SELECT c.commodity_id, c.name FROM commodities c WHERE c.tier IN ('service_professional', 'service_luxury') AND c.commodity_id IN (SELECT output_commodity_id FROM production_chains); -- Expected: 0 rows -- 805-7: Raw materials have NO producing chains (they are inputs, not outputs) SELECT c.commodity_id, c.name FROM commodities c WHERE c.tier = 'raw' AND c.commodity_id IN (SELECT output_commodity_id FROM production_chains); -- Expected: 0 rows (fusion_fuel is intermediate, not raw — verify separately) -- 805-8: Coverage rule — corporations per major commodity type (D-175: 3+ per major type) -- "Major commodity type" = intermediates and finals with demand_model = 'market' -- This requires corp_presence.primary_operation to reference a commodity_id; adjust -- query if the schema uses a different field. Flag if the field is absent. SELECT commodity_id, COUNT(DISTINCT cp.corp_id) AS corp_count FROM corp_presence cp JOIN corporations c ON cp.corp_id = c.corp_id WHERE cp.primary_operation IS NOT NULL GROUP BY cp.primary_operation HAVING corp_count < 3; -- Expected: 0 rows (every commodity with corp presence has 3+ corps) -- 805-9: Coverage rule — inhabited systems > 100K pop have at least one corp SELECT ss.system_id, ss.proper_name FROM star_systems ss JOIN system_economy se ON ss.system_id = se.system_id WHERE se.population > 100000 AND NOT EXISTS ( SELECT 1 FROM corp_presence cp JOIN bodies b ON cp.location_id = b.body_id AND cp.location_type = 'body' WHERE b.system_id = ss.system_id UNION SELECT 1 FROM corp_presence cp JOIN stations s ON cp.location_id = s.station_id AND cp.location_type = 'station' WHERE s.system_id = ss.system_id ); -- Expected: 0 rows ``` ### Exit code tests Run the pipeline with intentional violations and verify non-zero exit: **805-E1: Wiki name mismatch causes hard error** Temporarily rename a corporation in the DB to something the wiki doesn't know, re-run pipeline. Expected: non-zero exit with clear error message identifying the mismatch. **805-E2: Missing commodity coverage causes hard error** If coverage drops below 3 corps for any major commodity type, pipeline must exit non-zero. Expected: non-zero exit with specific commodity identified. **805-E3: Coverage failure for underpopulated system causes hard error** If an inhabited system with >100K pop has zero corp presence, pipeline must exit non-zero. Expected: non-zero exit with system_id identified. **805-E4: Dry-run still works** `python3 tooling/economy-db/import_economics.py --dry-run` must: - Not write to corp_presence - Run all validations and report but not halt on coverage gaps (dry-run output is informational) - Exit 0 (dry-run is for inspection, not a gate) Wait — check this with Dudley. If dry-run is meant to be a gate too, this should exit non-zero on validation failure. The existing pipeline exits 0 on dry-run. Confirm expected behavior before locking this test. ### Regression markers - BF-1 through BF-7 still pass (new pipeline must not corrupt commodity/chain data) - `corp_presence` table's FK constraint still enforced (BF-6 analog for corps) - Existing `gate_links` bidirectionality (BF-5) unaffected --- ## #806 — Skeleton Economy_sim Binary **Spec ref:** D-176, D-177, D-178 **Assigned to:** Dudley **Status:** backlog (blocked on #805) ### What was changed - New Rust binary at `tooling/econ-sim/` - Reads systems.db: gate_links, commodities, production_chains, chain_inputs, corp_presence - Seeds per-corp-site productivity (5 dimensions, PRNG, log-normal distribution) - Layer 1 Leontief only (no inter-system trade, no currency) - Outputs per-node CSV: node_id, commodity_id, supply, demand, price, tick - `--stability-check` flag compiles (stub, not yet meaningful) ### Build verification ```bash cd tooling/econ-sim && cargo build # Expected: exits 0, no compile errors tooling/econ-sim --help # Expected: help text with --db, --stability-check, and --output flags visible ``` ### CSV output verification ```bash tooling/econ-sim --db server/data/systems.db --output /tmp/econ_out.csv ``` **806-1:** CSV file is created at the specified path **806-2:** CSV header contains: `node_id,commodity_id,supply,demand,price,tick` **806-3:** Row count is `active_nodes × 36` (760 active nodes × 36 commodities = ~27,360 rows) - Acceptable range: ±10% of 27,360 (active node count may differ slightly from spec estimate) **806-4:** No `price` values are negative or zero for commodity types with non-zero base_price **806-5:** `tick` column is 0 for initial seeding output (first tick) ### Productivity seeding verification **806-6: Standard node range (D-176)** ```python # Pseudocode — inspect CSV output import csv, math prices = [float(row['price']) for row in csv.DictReader(open('/tmp/econ_out.csv'))] # For standard commodities, productivity multiplier range is 0.4–1.8x # Price variation relative to base_price should reflect this range base_price_by_id = { ... } # from commodities table multipliers = [price / base_price_by_id[row['commodity_id']] for row in rows] assert all(0.3 <= m <= 2.0 for m in multipliers), "multiplier out of expected range" # Actual range check: most values should fall within 0.4–1.8x (log-normal tails permitted) ``` **806-7: Monopoly-source node range (D-176)** Nodes producing `lattice_grade_material` (production_ubiquity = 'monopolistic') must show tighter multiplier range: 0.7–1.4×. Verify variance is lower than standard nodes. **806-8: D-177 constraints — what must NOT vary** Verify the binary never seeds or varies: - Location of production (the set of nodes producing each commodity is fixed from DB data, not random) - `lattice_grade_material` productivity: must stay within 0.7–1.4× (monopolistic ceiling) - Absence of seeded "starting disruptions" (no negative productivity, no corps with zero initial output as a seeded state) **806-9: Corridor correlation (D-176 ~0.6)** Nodes in the same geographic corridor should have correlated productivity across runs with similar PRNG seeds. Spot-check: run binary twice with seeds differing by 1; nodes in same corridor should show ~0.6 Pearson correlation on their multipliers. ### Stub stability check ```bash tooling/econ-sim --stability-check # Expected: exits with some non-panic output, even if it's "stability tests not yet implemented" # Must NOT crash or segfault ``` ### Regression markers - Atlas binary still builds: `cargo build --bin atlas` - D-177 lore constraints respected (see 806-8) --- ## #807 — Trade Flows and Stability Testing **Spec ref:** D-178, D-179 **Assigned to:** Dudley **Status:** backlog (blocked on #806) **This is the most critical ticket. D-179 defines the exit condition for Phase 2.** ### Tâtonnement parameters Verify from source code: - α = 0.03 (price adjustment speed) - β = 0.4 (damping coefficient) If these are configurable via CLI flags, document the defaults. If hardcoded, grep for them: ```bash grep -r "0\.03" tooling/econ-sim/src/ grep -r "0\.4" tooling/econ-sim/src/ ``` ### Floyd-Warshall startup performance ```bash time tooling/econ-sim --stability-check 2>&1 | head -5 # Expected: FW initialization completes in < 2s (D-178 spec: ~0.5s, allow 4x margin) # Flag if > 5s: likely iterating over all 3700 nodes instead of the ~760 active subgraph ``` ### Market node tiering (D-178) **807-1:** Active node count is approximately 760 (inhabited bodies + all stations) ```sql -- Count active market nodes per D-178 definition SELECT COUNT(*) FROM ( SELECT body_id AS node_id FROM bodies WHERE inhabited = 1 UNION ALL SELECT station_id FROM stations ); -- Expected: ~760 (accept 700–820 as the spec estimate may not match actual DB state) ``` **807-2:** Passive producer count is approximately 240 ```sql SELECT COUNT(*) FROM bodies WHERE inhabited = 0 AND population > 0; -- Expected: ~240 (bodies with economic activity but no market function) -- Adjust query based on how the sim defines "passive producer" ``` ### Transport cost model Verify in source or via output that: **807-3:** Gate edges cost 5–12% per hop (inter-system) **807-4:** Orbital edges cost 1–3% (intra-system) **807-5:** Transport costs are applied to commodity prices, not abstracted away ### D-179 Stability Tests ```bash tooling/econ-sim --stability-check ``` All four tests are run by this flag (Tests 1–2 in #807, Tests 3–4 in #808). After #807: **Test 1: Cold-start convergence (D-179)** - Simulate 100 game-days from cold start - Measure price deviation from equilibrium at tick 100 - **Pass criterion:** All active commodity prices within ±5% of equilibrium - **Fail indicators:** oscillation, monotonic drift, any price < 0 **Test 2: Long-run stability (D-179)** - Simulate 1,000 game-days with zero external events - Measure maximum price drift from tick-0 equilibrium - **Pass criterion:** Zero drift > ±2% over the full 1,000-tick run - **Fail indicators:** slow drift accumulation, oscillation amplitude > 2%, any negative price ### Stockpile buffer test **807-6:** Single-tick supply removal does not cause price explosion ``` procedure: 1. Run sim to equilibrium (100 ticks) 2. Inject a single tick of zero supply for one commodity at one node 3. Observe price at that node for next 5 ticks Expected: price rises but does not exceed 10× base_price Fail: price goes to infinity, NaN, or negative ``` ### Regression markers - Test 1 and Test 2 must pass with `--stability-check` before #808 begins - If either test fails: do NOT mark #807 done, do NOT proceed to #808 - α/β must be documented (in source comments or README) so future tuning is traceable --- ## #808 — Currency Zones and Exchange Rates **Spec ref:** D-171, D-172, D-174, D-181, D-186 **Assigned to:** Dudley **Status:** backlog (blocked on #807) ### Currency zone model **808-1:** Tractus↔Mark friction = ~3% Verify in cross-zone trade: cost of a commodity transiting from a TRACTUS_PRIMARY to a MARK_PRIMARY node is ~3% higher than same-zone transit at equal hop distance. **808-2:** Zero friction within MARK_PRIMARY zones Two nodes both in MARK_PRIMARY zones trading with each other incur no currency conversion cost beyond the standard transport cost. **808-3:** Sol is NOT a zone flag ```sql SELECT COUNT(*) FROM star_systems WHERE currency_zone = 'SOL_PRIMARY'; -- Expected: 0 (Sol is shadow economy only, D-171) ``` **808-4:** Exchange rate is driven by trade balance, not hardcoded The Tractus/Mark exchange rate must change between runs (or across ticks as trade flows change). Hardcoded rates are a test failure. ### Signal vocabulary (D-181) All 7 signals must be present in sim output per active node: **808-5:** ``` 1. price_current — present in output 2. price_trend — present in output (direction + rate) 3. trade_flow_volume — present in output 4. corporate_presence — present in output 5. stockpile_weeks — present in output 6. production_vs_baseline — present in output 7. official_coverage_ratio — present in output (derived from shadow_economy_intensity) ``` Edge case: For `official_coverage_ratio`, verify nodes with no shadow economy intensity (TRACTUS_PRIMARY core systems) produce `official_coverage_ratio = 1.0` (formal economy covers 100% of activity), not NULL. ### gate_energy_connected demand reduction (D-186) **808-6:** Nodes with `gate_energy_connected = true` show `fusion_fuel` demand ~0.3× baseline - Run sim on a TRACTUS_PRIMARY system (gate_energy_connected = true) - Run sim on a MARK_PRIMARY system (gate_energy_connected = false) - Compare `fusion_fuel` demand signal: on-grid node demand must be ~30% of off-grid **808-7:** Industrial chain inputs are NOT reduced (D-186) - `smelt_ore` still requires `fusion_fuel` at 0.3 coefficient regardless of gate energy - `alloy_fabrication` still requires `fusion_fuel` at 0.2 coefficient - `electronics_fabrication` still requires `fusion_fuel` at 0.2 coefficient ### D-179 Tests 3–4 **Test 3: Shock response (D-179)** - Apply a single supply shock to one commodity at one node - **Pass criteria:** - Cascade propagates to dependent commodities (Leontief input scarcity visible) - Recovery to within 10% of pre-shock price within 200 ticks - No price explosions (no value > 100× base_price) - No negative prices - **Fail indicators:** runaway cascade, no recovery, shock isolated (no cascade = broken Leontief) **Test 4: Cross-zone trade balance (D-179)** - Increase trade volume across a TRACTUS_PRIMARY / MARK_PRIMARY boundary - **Pass criteria:** - Exchange rate adjusts in response (Tractus/Mark ratio changes) - Rate re-stabilizes within 50 ticks - Friction cost is visible (cross-zone goods 3% more expensive than same-zone equivalent) - **Fail indicators:** no rate adjustment, infinite oscillation, rate diverges All four D-179 tests must pass before #809 begins. ### Regression markers - Tests 1 and 2 from #807 must still pass with currency layer active - Tractus prices are still the numeraire (no price expressed in Mark or Sol units) --- ## #809 — Corporate Agent Behavior **Spec ref:** D-175, D-178, D-180, D-181 **Assigned to:** Dudley **Status:** backlog (blocked on #808, #799, #800) ### Corporate data loading **809-1:** Corporations are loaded from DB, not hardcoded ```bash grep -r "hardcoded\|\"Gate Corporation\"\|\"Vethara\"" tooling/econ-sim/src/ # Expected: corporation names should appear only in test fixtures or SQL queries, # not as string literals in behavioral logic ``` **809-2:** Behavioral archetype template is read from TOML ```bash ls wiki/economics/archetypes/behavioral.toml # Expected: file exists (created by copy team per sprint briefing) ``` **809-3:** Each archetype is instantiated per corporation from corp_presence ```sql -- Every corporation with corp_presence rows has a behavioral_archetype in DB SELECT COUNT(*) FROM corp_presence cp JOIN corporations c ON cp.corp_id = c.corp_id WHERE c.behavioral_archetype IS NULL; -- Expected: 0 (all corps with presence have an archetype assigned) ``` ### Six behavioral archetypes (D-175) **809-4:** All 6 archetypes are implemented ```bash grep -r "Monopolist\|Distributor\|Producer\|Specialist\|Cooperative\|Intermediary" \ tooling/econ-sim/src/ # Expected: all 6 appear in behavioral logic, not just data loading ``` **809-5:** Archetypes produce distinguishably different behavior Run stability check with only Monopolist corps vs. only Cooperative corps in a test system. Price signals should differ between the two runs. If all archetypes produce identical output, the behavioral differentiation is not implemented. ### EconEvent stub (D-180) **809-6:** EconEvent struct compiles with all required fields ```bash grep -r "EconEvent" tooling/econ-sim/src/ # Expected: struct definition with: target, effect, duration, visibility fields ``` **809-7:** Visibility variants are defined ```bash grep -r "Global\|Proximate\|Disclosed\|Hidden" tooling/econ-sim/src/ # Expected: all 4 visibility variants present in the EconEvent type ``` **809-8:** Event handler is a no-op (not exercised in Phase 2) Any call to `handle_event(EconEvent { ... })` should produce no observable simulation change. The port must compile and accept events without crashing. ### Signal completeness (D-181) **809-9:** All 7 signals produced per active node with agents active Repeat 808-5 checks with corporate agents running. Agent behavior must not suppress or break signal production. **809-10:** `production_vs_baseline` reflects agent output vs seeded baseline A Monopolist corp restricting supply should show `production_vs_baseline < 1.0`. A Cooperative corp operating at full capacity should show `production_vs_baseline ≈ 1.0`. ### D-179 Full Test Suite with Agents Active **This is the Phase 2 exit condition.** ```bash tooling/econ-sim --stability-check ``` **809-11:** All four stability tests pass with corporate agents active: - Test 1: Cold-start convergence ±5% within 100 game-days - Test 2: Long-run stability ±2% over 1,000 game-days - Test 3: Shock response, recovery within 200 ticks, no explosions or negatives - Test 4: Cross-zone balance re-stabilizes within 50 ticks If agents CAUSE instability that wasn't present in #808, the agent behavioral parameters need tuning — this is a model bug, not a design decision. Investigate price-setting behavior before concluding the architecture is wrong. ### Regression markers - All prior D-179 tests still pass - EconEvent handler does not crash on any valid input permutation - `behavioral.toml` is a required file — binary must error on missing file with a clear message --- ## Checklist: Verification Order | Order | Ticket | Gate condition | Who verifies | |-------|--------|----------------|--------------| | 1 | Pre-flight BF-1–7 | DB baseline valid | Hoshe, post #804 | | 2 | #813 | Schema correct, defaults correct | Hoshe, when Tyre delivers | | 3 | #805 | corp_presence populated, coverage valid, exits non-zero on failure | Hoshe, when Dudley delivers | | 4 | #806 | Binary builds, CSV output correct, seeding in range | Hoshe, when Dudley delivers | | 5 | #807 | Tests 1+2 pass `--stability-check` | Hoshe, when Dudley delivers | | 6 | #808 | Tests 3+4 pass, all 7 signals present | Hoshe, when Dudley delivers | | 7 | #809 | All 4 D-179 tests pass with agents active | Hoshe, when Dudley delivers | **Phase 2 is complete only when step 7 passes.** Steps 5 through 7 are the formal exit gate per D-179 and D-183. --- ## Appendix: Quick Reference — D-179 Stability Criteria | Test | Condition | Pass threshold | Run at | |------|-----------|---------------|--------| | 1 | Cold-start convergence | ±5% of equilibrium within 100 game-days | #807 | | 2 | Long-run stability | ±2% drift over 1,000 game-days, zero events | #807 | | 3 | Shock response | Recovery within 200 ticks, no explosions, no negatives | #808 | | 4 | Cross-zone trade balance | Re-stabilizes within 50 ticks | #808 | All four must pass simultaneously with corporate agents active (#809) for Phase 2 sign-off.